Hausfeld responds to Law Commission review of consumer class actions

Hausfeld submitted its response to the Law Commission’s recent questionnaire on the possible introduction of a consumer class action regime in England and Wales. The Commission will assess the potential benefits and risks of a collective mechanism alongside existing mechanisms, including public enforcement and alternative dispute resolution and consider how any new regime should be designed.

In it, Hausfeld supports extending the opt-out collective redress beyond competition law. There is no principled reason why collective redress should be confined to competition law, when similar patterns of dispersed harm exist across other sectors.

The existing patchwork of procedural rules under Group Litigation Orders and representative actions under CPR 19.8 all too often do not provide consumers with an effective right to redress nor deter companies from unlawful conduct.  This position is in contrast to other jurisdictions in Europe, Canada and Australia which have established collective mechanisms which extend across all sectors.  There is also no principled reason for limiting access to justice to consumers when SMEs often suffer the exact same harm and face the same obstacles to enforcing their rights.  

Nicola Boyle, Managing Partner at Hausfeld in London:
 
“Drawing on our experience of collective proceedings before the Competition Appeal Tribunal, we set out how an opt-out consumer class action regime would bring important benefits in enhancing consumer protection: improved access to justice, a stronger deterrence of unlawful conduct, improved consumer protection and a level playing field for compliant businesses while complementing public enforcement and offering greater procedural efficiency. We also identify the safeguards needed to ensure that meritorious claims can proceed while claims lacking merit are filtered out. These include a clear and proportionate certification test, effective judicial oversight and access to viable litigation funding.”
 
Hausfeld’s response in a nutshell:
 
Group Litigation Orders and representative actions under CPR 19.8 do not provide a consistently effective means of resolving mass consumer claims. The UK’s established competition collective proceedings regime provides a strong foundation for a broader consumer regime. 

Concerns about speculative litigation are overstated. It is unsurprising that the introduction of a collective redress mechanism resulted in more claims being brought compared to the absence of such a mechanism where legitimate claims had not previously been possible. That does not, however, mean frivolous claims will be brought. The combination of clear, predictable and proportionate certification, strike-out powers, costs rules and the stringent due diligence undertaken by claimant firms, funders and insurers can provide effective safeguards against claims lacking merit.

Litigation funding is essential to access to justice where a large number of consumers have each suffered a relatively small loss. Hausfeld supports increasing the available funding options, including permitting damages-based agreements and percentage-based funding arrangements which should assist in extending funding options and can protect consumers’ interests. 

A well-designed regime would complement public enforcement, strengthen deterrence and promote a level playing field by ensuring that businesses complying with consumer law are not disadvantaged against those profiting from unlawful practices. It could also reduce duplication, costs and demands on court resources by resolving common issues in a single set of proceedings. 

The principal concern is not the opt-out model itself, but the risk of a poorly designed regime creating procedural complexity, uncertainty or barriers to funding. 

The design of the regime should focus on ensuring that compensation actually reaches affected consumers and brings an end to unlawful conduct. Several flexible distribution methods can be applied, such as direct payments, account credits and automatic reimbursements, alongside a trusted government-backed portal providing information about claims and compensation schemes. 

Pivotal to any consumer class action regime is that it should not be allowed to turn into a war of attrition, in which consumers face defendants with the strategic incentive and financial ability to drive up costs needlessly and put pressure on funding budgets and insurance cover. The courts should be alert to such litigation tactics. We welcome the Government’s proposal, in its consultation on Swifter and Simpler Competition Redress, to strengthen judicial budgetary oversight. 

Any damages that cannot be distributed should continue to benefit consumers and access to justice, rather than being returned to an unsuccessful defendant. As with the introduction of the competition regime, it is important to recognise that bringing unlawful conduct to an end and associated deterrence effect is also a key aim of the regime and use of undistributed funds can be effectively distributed indirectly either on a cy pres basis or to further access to justice for consumers through support for law centres and other pro bono schemes.  
 
In conclusion, the design of any consumer class actions regime should seek to strike an appropriate balance. Safeguards should be sufficient to prevent unmeritorious claims from progressing but should not be so onerous that they deny consumers an effective means of obtaining redress for widespread harms. The experience of the CAT regime demonstrates that this balance can be achieved.

The full response to the Law Commission’s consultation

OTHER NEWS